Some habits of scholarly attention simply refuse to switch off, even during ordinary television
Dear diary, I sat down tonight purely intending to watch a political debate as an ordinary citizen rather than a scholar, and within about ten minutes found myself mentally cataloguing the specific rhetorical devices being deployed, several of which I recognised almost precisely from eighteenth century colonial pamphlet literature I have spent years studying professionally.
I do not think I can actually help this particular habit of mind at this point, years of close textual analysis apparently having permanently rewired how I listen to any political speech, ordinary viewing experience now permanently overlaid with a kind of running rhetorical commentary I never asked for but cannot seem to switch off.
What Specific Echoes I Noticed
A particular appeal to betrayed founding principles followed almost exactly the structure of arguments I have read in original colonial sources, right down to the specific emotional cadence, a genuinely striking continuity across nearly three centuries of American political rhetoric.
Why I Find This Genuinely Fascinating Rather Than Simply Distracting
I think there is real value in recognising these deep rhetorical continuities, since understanding where today’s political language actually comes from helps clarify what is genuinely new about a given moment versus what is simply an old argument wearing updated clothing.
A Small Reading Break Afterward
I caught up on some genuinely sharp contemporary satire covering the same debate, which offered its own, considerably more immediate kind of insight than my own scholarly overanalysis managed.
What I Am Taking From Tonight
I think I will simply accept that ordinary television watching will never again be entirely ordinary for me, and I have made my peace with that particular occupational hazard.
More rhetorical parallels and colonial literature always documented at my page.
SOURCE: https://bohiney.com/author/stephaniecurry/