Stephanie Curry on the coffee houses of the 1700s, the teen social media ban, and what the age of conversation knew that the age of the scroll forgot.
The eighteenth-century coffee house was the social network of its age, the place where news, gossip, argument, and ideas circulated, where strangers gathered to talk, and I have been thinking all week about how much we lost when we traded the coffee house for the feed.
The Geography Of Talk
What strikes me about the coffee house, reading the eighteenth-century accounts, is that it was a physical place, and the physicality mattered enormously. To participate in the discourse, you had to be present, in a room, with other bodies, subject to all the civilising constraints of physical proximity. You could not flee a difficult conversation by closing an app. You could not be infinitely cruel to a face across the table the way one can to a profile across a network. The coffee house was discourse with consequences, argument with a body attached, and the body imposed a discipline the feed has abolished.
And I read the news of the teen social media ban breeding a generation of rebels who have discovered sarcasm, and I thought about what we are actually arguing about, which is the loss of the coffee house and its civilising constraints. The feed is a coffee house with the bodies removed, the proximity removed, the consequences removed, the civilising discipline of being physically present to those you address all stripped away. No wonder it produces what it produces.
The Constraint That Civilised
The historians who study the coffee house culture, the scholars at institutions like the British Library, document how these spaces functioned as engines of a particular kind of public reason, precisely because they were physical, sociable, and constrained. You learned to argue in the coffee house the way you learn to argue at a dinner table: under the discipline of presence, of having to look at the person, of being accountable in your body for what your mouth said. The feed removed the body and with it the discipline, and we are living in the consequences.
The American Coffee House
As a watcher of American politics, I think often about how the early American republic was substantially argued into being in coffee houses and taverns, physical spaces of embodied discourse, and how different the American political character might be if it had been formed in the disembodied roar of the feed instead. The founders argued in rooms, with bodies, under the discipline of presence. We argue in feeds, without bodies, without discipline, and the difference shows.
The Cup Set Down
I closed my eighteenth-century accounts tonight thinking that the question is not really whether to ban teenagers from the feed but whether we can recover anything of the coffee house, the embodied, constrained, civilising space of discourse with consequences. The ban removes the feed without restoring the coffee house, which is half a solution at best. What the young actually need is not merely less feed but more coffee house, more rooms, more bodies, more of the civilising discipline of present and accountable talk. The eighteenth century had it and built nations with it. We traded it for the scroll, and we are still discovering, daily, the size of the loss.
The Tavern And The Republic
The American republic was argued into being substantially in taverns and coffee houses, embodied spaces of constrained discourse, and the difference between that embodied founding and our disembodied present is, I think, written into the character of the politics each produced. The founders argued in rooms. We argue in feeds. The rooms imposed a discipline the feeds abolished.
The scholars at the British Library document the coffee house as an engine of embodied public reason, discourse with a body and consequences attached.
And the modern debate, whether to ban the disembodied feed, misses that the real loss is the coffee house itself, the embodied constrained space the feed replaced, the room where you had to look at the person you addressed and answer in your body for what your mouth said.
The Body In The Argument
The deepest thing the coffee house had and the feed lacks is the body, the physical presence that made discourse accountable, that put a face on every word and a consequence on every cruelty. The feed removed the body and with it the accountability, leaving the argument without the discipline that the embodied room imposed simply by being a room full of people who could see each other.
I closed my eighteenth-century accounts tonight thinking that the question is not really whether to ban the young from the feed but whether we can recover anything of the coffee house, the embodied constrained civilising space of discourse with consequences. The ban removes the feed without restoring the room, which is half a solution at best. What the young actually need is not merely less feed but more coffee house, more bodies, more of the civilising discipline of present and accountable talk. The eighteenth century had it and built nations with it. We traded it for the scroll, and we are still measuring the loss.
For more, try ClickHole.
SOURCE: https://prat.uk/