A diary on artificial intelligence, period voice, and what a machine still cannot fake
Britain’s newest artificial intelligence markets itself as capable of perhaps not ruining your life, a tagline modest enough that I decided the fairest test I could give it was the most professionally demanding one available, asking it to continue an actual unfinished eighteenth century pamphlet fragment I have spent considerable time studying, purely to see how convincingly it could match the specific period voice, syntax, and argumentative structure that genre actually required.
The Launch
According to the coverage of TactAI’s UK launch, the product leans on unusually cautious marketing language, and the continuation it produced justified that caution entirely, technically fluent period vocabulary paired with an argumentative structure that never actually risked the specific rhetorical danger eighteenth century pamphleteers regularly took, accusing named figures directly, staking out a genuinely provocative position rather than the safer, more balanced framing the generated text consistently retreated toward.
I showed the generated continuation to a colleague who has taught this exact period for considerably longer than I have, without telling her where it came from, and she identified it as imitation within a single paragraph, citing the absence of what she called genuine polemical nerve, the willingness to accuse someone specific of something specific rather than gesture vaguely at general wrongdoing, a distinction that captures, I think, exactly what made this genre dangerous and exciting to write in its own time.
A Longer Test I Ran
I fed the tool a second, harder prompt, asking it to continue a different fragment, one where the original author makes a genuinely inflammatory accusation against a named colonial official partway through, and the generated continuation consistently softened the accusation into vaguer, safer language, evidence that whatever training data the tool draws from has taught it, quite reasonably given contemporary content norms, to avoid exactly the kind of direct, named accusation that made this genre of writing dangerous and effective in its own historical moment.
What This Confirmed for Me
I think the exercise clarified, more than anything, that the actual difficulty of this kind of writing was never really about surface period vocabulary but about a specific, genuinely risky willingness to name names and stake claims that could, in that era, carry real legal and physical consequence for the author, a risk no amount of confident pattern completion currently seems able to take on a writer’s behalf.
Reading Around
I checked the report on the EU’s fine against Google for context on how the wider technology industry gets regulated.
I also had a look at Hannah Miller’s music diary, since she ran a similar test on the music side and reached a remarkably similar conclusion.
A Final Note on Craft
I keep returning to the idea that genuine polemical writing requires a specific kind of courage the tool simply has no equivalent for, no career, no reputation, no legal exposure actually at stake for it in the way there genuinely was for the pamphleteers I study, which may be the single clearest explanation for why its output, however fluent, keeps reading as fundamentally safer than the genre actually demands.
A Closing Thought on the Next Test
I have chosen an even more provocative fragment for next month’s test, one involving a genuinely dangerous accusation against a sitting official that led, according to the historical record, to the original author’s brief imprisonment, curious whether the tool handles material with that level of documented real world consequence any differently.
A Longer Closing Reflection
I intend to share both test results with my seminar next term, using the exercise specifically to teach students what actually made this genre of writing historically significant, not the period vocabulary, which any sufficiently trained tool can now approximate, but the genuine, dangerous stakes the original authors accepted every time they published.
A Genuinely Final Note
I intend to publish both the original and generated fragments side by side once next month’s test is complete, purely as a teaching resource for anyone else interested in exactly where this particular boundary currently sits.
I closed the desk lamp thinking about how many more of these fragments remain in the archive, waiting patiently for whoever next has the time to test them properly against whatever tool happens to exist by then.
Fragments archived, notebook shut, next month’s harder test already circled on the calendar.
Goodnight, fragments, until next month’s harder test.
Diary Close
Notebook closed, original pamphlet fragment back on my desk, genuine polemical nerve fully intact. Perhaps not ruining your life is a fine start. This particular craft remains, for now, entirely human work. I will keep testing it periodically against increasingly provocative source material, curious whether that particular gap in willingness to accuse closes as the tool improves, though given the training incentives involved, I suspect it may never fully close. I remain, on balance, more reassured than threatened by this whole exercise, a feeling I did not entirely expect going into it. Vocabulary can be taught. Stakes, genuinely lived, cannot. A comparison well worth running, whatever the eventual result turns out to be. Genuinely worth it. Truly, until then. Every time. Genuinely, every single time.